Friday, 20 November 2026

DO YOU KNOW, FR GRAYLAND, THAT "SIN MAKES YOU STUPID"


To comment please open your gmail account or use my email address, FB Messenger or X









At last! New Zealand has a Catholic bishop in deed as well as word. And he doesn't mind Rome knowing it. 



Bishop John Adams of Palmerston North Diocese will celebrate Advent Masses at the cathedral during Advent ad orientem - literally meaning facing east, in fact meaning facing the altar, the crucifix and the tabernacle (ie. facing God) instead of facing the congregation (versus populum). 



Bishop Adams is a brave man. He doesn't mind Rome knowing. Or the whole Catholic world knowing, via the UK's Catholic Herald. And Complicit Clergy. And Lifesitenews. And Ad Vaticanum. These Catholic websites all reported the big news from New Zealand without comment. 



Not so Fr Joseph Grayland, that enfant terrible of Palmerston North Diocese now fittingly residing in Germany with the Synodaler Weg, his progressivist, ideological home away from home. He lectures Germans on theology, presumably as he lectured New Zealanders on theology; that is to say, through a synodal/modernist, post-Vatican II lens. 



So now Fr Grayland rears up on his hind legs to accuse the good Bishop Adams of using the term "my Mass". Fr Grayland is disingenuous. Rather like Jorge Bergoglio aka 'Pope Francis', when he skewed the world's bishops' CDF survey to justify his totally unjustifiable Traditionis Custodes. Or maybe Grayland is losing the plot. He's still banging the worn-out drum of participation. And introduces 'Pope Leo XIV' s notion of 'human dignity'. 



We may have to wait for the inevitable: a long-winded word salad from Palmerston North's Emeritus Bishop Peter Cullinane, who's bound to weigh in on this topic. Probably in 'Flashes of Insight', which published Fr Grayland's piece - as it would, as it was founded by Fr Grayland himself. In relation to Tradition, truth and the deposit of Faith, a more accurate title would be 'Flashes of Cordite'.



Nowhere does Bishop Adams refer to 'my Mass'. Nowhere. Check his text for yourself: https://tumanako.pndiocese.org.nz/2026/11/from-the-bishops-desk-facing-the-lord-together-this-advent/ 



He says, "my Masses". Plural. He says this obviously to differentiate between the Masses he himself will celebrate in the cathedral, and Masses which will be said by other priests as scheduled, because as he says, he is " not asking other priests to do this necessarily." One would think that a lecturer in theology (even an assistant lecturer like Grayland) would understand as much. But Grayland fails also to discern the difference between "Christ ... present in the Eucharistic assembly, the proclaimed Word, the ordained minister, and the sacramental species". 



It's the Novus Ordo effect. 60-something years of taking the Lord of heaven and earth in the hand like a potato crisp has obliterated the faith which knows the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ cannot be evaluated on the same plane as His word in Scripture, or a merely human priest and congregation. Neither is Bishop Adams expressing an 'individual liturgical preference'. 



Ad orientem is the preference of the Church: Sacrosanctum Concilium and the Novus Ordo Missae stipulated that Mass was to be celebrated ad orientem, in Latin, with Gregorian chant and Communion on the tongue. The thing is, exceptions gradually emerged, and the new Mass evolved into what it is today - something of a dog's breakfast. The Second Vatican Council said nothing about the direction of the celebrant during Mass but presupposed ad orientem, as intended by Vatican II and immemorial Tradition.



Fretting about priest and people facing the altar, the crucifix and the Holy Eucharist rather than eyeballing one another suggests, Bishop D E Meikle says, that the problem is rejection of the Old Faith. "They would rather face a recycling bin, a Pachamama or a hammer and sickle than the True God."



Fr Grayland is in good company. Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago banned Masses ad orientem in his diocese in 2021.




Speaking of good company - Cardinal Cupich with Cardinal McCarrick of unhappy memory




The most devastating effect of the Novus Ordo is that of cumulative sin. Grayland worries about the congregation not understanding why they should face God in order to worship Him. He thinks it's about recognising the baptismal dignity of those who constitute the worshipping assembly. A worshipping assembly which lines up to receive the Holy Eucharist in the hand from lay people, which because of the paucity of thought, mystery and reverence in their New Mass is ignorant of dogma and doctrine, and consequently of the nature and consequences of sin is unrepentant and unconfessed, has lost its baptismal dignity. 



In other words, such a worshipping assembly is not generally in a state of grace. Catholics are bound (required) to learn and know their Faith. A sin against faith (often caused by willful ignorance) is the gravest of all sins, according to St Thomas Aquinas: "sin against faith divides man from God as far as possible, since it deprives him of the true knowledge of God; it therefore follows that sin against faith is the greatest of all sins."



Renowned exorcist Fr Chad Ripperger notes that ignorance and subsequent sins cloud judgement,  make people prone to excess or defect in assessing reality, and form bad intellectual habits. Each sin weakens the intellect's ability to see truth clearly by habituating it to ignore the moral reality of actions in favour of desired goods.



In other words, Fr Grayland, "sin makes you stupid".





"No pastor may reserve these functions to men."
                                                    


A Catholic bishop in New Zealand announced that all cathedral Masses in his diocese during Advent will be celebrated facing the sanctuary to strike a blow against “clericalism” in the liturgy.

 

On November 3, Bishop John Adams of Palmerston North, New Zealand, announced in a diocesan reflection that he will celebrate all Sunday and weekday Advent Masses at his cathedral ad orientem, with both the priest and the congregation facing the same direction toward God.

 

Addressing the widespread distraction caused by modern liturgical arrangements, Adams argued that celebrating Mass facing the people fostered an unhealthy focus on the celebrant rather than on the divine sacrifice.

 

“We can almost develop a ‘game show host’ culture,” the prelate wrote, explaining that under the dominant post-conciliar practice, “if the priest is lively and engaging, we think the parish is doing well; if he is quieter or less outgoing, we think the parish is doing poorly.”

 

“The Mass is not about the priest. It never should be,” Adams emphasized. “Making his personality the centre of our worship is a form of clericalism. In my view, one remedy is for priest and people to face the same way, reminding us that we are together in offering our worship to God.”

 

READ: Fr. Altman blasts ‘total apostasy’ at the Vatican under Pope Leo

 

Referencing Pope Francis’s synodal phrase “widening the tent,” the New Zealand bishop noted that traditional liturgical practices have been routinely marginalized while progressive novelties are freely embraced.

 

“In my view, we have tended to widen the tent on what we might call the  progressive side of the Church,” Adams stated. “A tent needs support on both sides if it is to stand, and there is a legitimate diversity within the Church that we should recognise and strengthen.”

 

Clarifying the liturgical nature of the decision, Adams stressed that celebrating ad orientem requires no alteration to the text of the Roman Missal, as current rubrics already presume that the priest and congregation face liturgical east together, with specific instructions for the celebrant to turn toward the people at designated moments.

 

 

However, the bishop noted that he intends to return to facing the congregation for his Christmas Masses.

 

The historic practice of celebrating Mass ad orientem, namely, facing east toward the rising sun as a symbol of the resurrected Christ, was maintained universally across both Western and Eastern rites for over a millennium and a half.

 

Following the liturgical reforms that implemented the Novus Ordo Missae after the Second Vatican Council, the practice of facing the people, versus populum, spread rapidly across dioceses worldwide.

 

Although turning the altar toward the congregation was never mandated by conciliar documents or the official rubrics of the modern Missal, it quickly became an enforced ideological norm in most parishes, drastically changing how Catholics perceive the Mass.

 

In recent decades, eminent Church figures repeatedly called for a return to ad orientem worship. For example, Cardinal Robert Sarah, formerly the prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship, publicly urged all bishops and priests to return to celebrating Mass facing liturgical east. His recommendation echoed earlier theological writings by Pope Benedict XVI, who warned that turning the priest toward the people risks turning the liturgy into a self-enclosed circle focused on man rather than God.https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/bishop-says-priests-facing-the-people-during-mass-risks-game-show-host-culture



Taking the mickey out of versus populum 

                          


 

When a bishop or priest begins explaining a liturgical change with the words “my Mass”, alarm bells should ring.

 

Two words reveal a fundamental problem in the Church: the privatisation of its public worship.

 

The Mass is not his. It belongs to Christ and his Church.

 

Facing the Lord

 

Celebrating Mass ad orientem illustrates the problem, especially when its justification invokes the idea of “facing the Lord together”, suggesting that priest and people facing the same physical direction somehow express a more authentic orientation towards God.

 

But this is theological nonsense if it implies that a congregation celebrating versus populum is not already facing the Lord.

 

The Eucharist is directed toward the Father through Christ in the Holy Spirit, not through the priest’s geographical orientation. Christ is present in the Eucharistic assembly, the proclaimed Word, the ordained minister, and the sacramental species (Sacrosanctum Concilium 7).

 

Turning the priest around does not make Christ more present.

 

Nor does it eliminate clericalism. It may simply turn clericalism around.

 

Preference versus participation

 

The deeper problem is the assumption that an ordained minister’s personal liturgical preference provides sufficient justification for changing the ritual experience of an entire community.

 

The Second Vatican Council explicitly teaches that liturgical celebrations are not private functions but actions of the whole Church (SC 26). It also prohibits anyone, including priests, from changing the liturgy on personal authority (SC 22 §3).

 

Authority is not ownership

 

Of course, ad orientem is a legitimate liturgical practice. Bishops possess real authority, and the liturgical books permit certain choices. But permission is not pastoral justification, and authority is not ownership.

 

A significant change in established worship deserves consultation, explanation, and genuine faith formation. The faithful need more than an announcement explaining what the priest intends to do. They need to understand why the change matters for their participation in the Eucharistic mystery.

 

This is not about submitting liturgy to majority vote. It is about recognising the baptismal dignity of those who constitute the worshipping assembly.

 

Here lies the extraordinary irony. A bishop may claim to be correcting priest-centred worship while exercising precisely the clerical control that makes the priest the determining subject of the celebration.

 

Such thinking perpetuates a pre-conciliar clericalist mentality in which the priest acts, and the people follow. It contradicts the Council’s fundamental insistence on actuosa participatio: the full, conscious, and active participation of all the baptised (SC 14).

 

Servant or proprietor

 

The issue is not whether the cleric faces east or faces the people. Both orientations can express authentic worship if they genuinely reflect active participation. However, both can also accommodate clericalism.

 

The question is whether the priest understands himself as the servant of the Church’s liturgy or its proprietor.

 

The Church does not need clergy who claim to face the Lord while disregarding the people with whom they celebrate.

 

The real direction of liturgical reform is not geographical. It is for the Church to decide.

 

The Mass is never “my Mass”. It is always the Eucharist of Christ and his Church.

  • Dr Joe Grayland, a priest of the Catholic Diocese of Palmerston North, New Zealand, is a lecturer in the Department of Liturgy at the University of Wuerzburg (Germany).https://flashesinsight.com/2026/11/17/when-the-mass-becomes-a-clerics-private-property/



 

Michel I Corneille, La Présentation de la Vierge au Temple


O Blessed Virgin Mary, presented in the Temple, pray for us who have recourse to Thee

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

LEO KEEPS FRANCIS' TRADITONIS CUSTODES

 

To comment please open your gmail account or use my email address, FB Messenger or X (Twitter). Please note that comments will not be posted on this page without permission  







For faithful Catholics it's nothing short of blood-curdling. The Traditional Latin Mass safeguarded forever by Pope St Pius V in Quo Primum Tempore (1570) is nonchalantly refused to the Church once again by an antichurch antipope, airborne on yet another international junket. 


"Traditionis Custodes is the decision of Francis, and we will continue to follow it."


So much for reversing Bergoglian evils and error: Robert Prevost, the self-identified idolater and heretic known fondly by the world as 'Pope Leo XIV', declared yesterday that he would continue to enforce the infamous Traditionis Custodes. It's particularly galling for traditional Catholics to reflect on the smirk likely worn right now by Cardinal Arthur Roche, that adornment of the conciliar counter church who pre-empted its latest strike against the Most Holy Eucharist.


Never mind that TC contradicts Pope Benedict XVI's Summorum Pontificum, and so cannot be legitimate. Never mind that Prevost is implicitly admitting the existence of two separate Churches, one which defends the deposit of the Catholic faith and the other, Synodal, religion which seeks to destroy it. Never mind that no priest anywhere in the world can lawfully be forbidden to celebrate the Mass of Ages. 


Rome is evidently indifferent to all the above, and careless of faithful Catholics' distress, and to the loss of millions of souls whom Our Lady once said "fall into hell like snowflakes": to the Vatican it seems to matter not. Satan, evidently in a hurry to finish his nasty work, is whipping his minions on to its evil conclusion. So Prevost confidently declares that "the vast majority of Catholics will continue celebrating the Novus Ordo Missae of Paul VI." 


Only because they're forced by the lack of an alternative and/or because they know nothing better. Yes, there are dispensations, but the current crop of Bergoglian bishops rarely grants them. In fact, Prevost is aggressively implementing TC. 


But the Pollyannas are still around.  "It could have been so much worse." "He’s allowing himself (and bishops) a lot of freedom for manoeuvre." They alight on Prevost's phrase, "No, not right now" in answer to the $64,000 question "will you rescind Traditionis Custodes", as if it were a token of his good will rather than evasiveness.


Then there's the rare realist who says "Truly accepting Leo's papacy will require accepting Francis's as well."  


And that's about the size of it, people. Although the records show that neither Paul VI nor Vatican II ever abrogated the Latin Mass. Although in the late ’60s, Paul VI and even the Freemason Father Annibale Bugnini, architect of the New Mass, went on record to say that the Traditional Latin Mass was to be kept and encouraged. Although in 2007, Pope Benedict XVI reiterated that the TLM was never forbidden by the Council.


Jorge Bergoglio's Traditionis Custodes was an act of violent spiritual abuse, inflicted on the Church under false pretences. He misrepresented a consultation with the world's bishops as the fundamental role in his decision to restrict the traditional Mass severely, when in fact their message had been to leave Summorum Pontificum alone.

So Prevost now proposes to perpetuate an act of false pretences by ducking his responsibility for the Mass of Ages. Instead he's giving bishops (who saw no need for it) the power and responsibility of granting indults (permissions, for a Mass they saw as a right) while making it abundantly clear that if the bishops know what's good for them (for their careers, that is, not their souls) they won't grant said indults.

That's how the preposterous Prevost and his perps can abolish the TLM de facto while actually keeping it de jure (untouched on paper). It's literally fiendishly cunning. Almost as if it had been devised by the king of fiends - Satan himself. 


In order to kill the Mass of Ages stone dead.  


'Coexist' - but only in the meantime, he means 


From Lifesitenews:

ABOARD THE PAPAL PLANE (LifeSiteNews) — Pope Leo XIV declared that he will continue enforcing Pope Francis’s Traditionis Custodes restrictions on the Latin Mass in the name of Church unity.

 

Yesterday, during an in-flight press conference while returning to Rome from his apostolic journey to South America, Pope Leo confirmed that his administration will maintain Pope Francis’s 2021 motu proprio restricting the Traditional Latin Mass while affirming that the vast majority of Catholics will continue celebrating the Novus Ordo Missae of Paul VI.

 

In response to a Le Figaro correspondent who asked the Pope whether he was considering the possibility of moving beyond or revoking Traditionis Custodes, Leo replied: “Not right now. Traditions Custodes is the decision of Francis, and we will continue to follow it.”

 

 

Justifying the ongoing restrictions, the Pope insisted that liturgical uniformity under the post-conciliar rite remains essential for ecclesiastical unity. “For the unity of the Church,” the Pope highlighted, “the vast majority of Catholics around the world celebrate the rite of Vatican II, of Paul VI, and we will continue to do that.” He added: “There is an avenue available for those who wish to apply for the dispensation.”

 

By framing adherence to the post-conciliar liturgy as a matter of “unity,” Pope Leo XIV reinforces the rhetoric utilized during the previous pontificate to marginalize traditionalist communities.

 

His remarks aboard the papal plane follow a two-week tour of South America – covering Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru – during which the Pontiff repeatedly promoted the unity of the “synodal Church” and called for structural continuity with the agenda of Pope Francis.

 

In 2007, Pope Benedict XVI issued the landmark motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, acknowledging that the Traditional Latin Mass had never been abrogated and affirming every Latin-rite priest the freedom to celebrate it without asking for permission from their bishop. Benedict’s decree led to a massive resurgence of vocations for traditionalist communities, youth engagement, and thriving parish communities across the globe.

 

However, in July 2021, Pope Francis overturned Benedict XVI’s reconciliation efforts by issuing Traditionis Custodes. Francis declared the Novus Ordo to be the “unique expression of the Roman Rite,” restricted the establishment of new traditionalist groups, and required priests to obtain explicit diocesan and Vatican authorization to offer the ancient Mass.

 

Following the election of Pope Leo XIV in May 2025, many traditionalist Catholics harbored hopes that the new Pontiff might grant a liturgical truce or restore canonical protection to traditionalist groups in the Church.

 

However, Leo XIV’s latest declarations aboard the papal plane extinguish those expectations, confirming unbroken continuity with post-conciliar liturgical policies.https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/breaking-leo-xiv-vows-to-maintain-pope-francis-restrictions-on-latin-mass/



 

                               


 

The co-author of a book exposing the misconceptions that have served as the basis for the Latin Mass-suppressing Traditionis Custodes has recently shared some of his findings.

 

Trads: Latin Mass Catholics in the United States, provides an in-depth exploration of the views and characteristics of Catholics who attend the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM), revealing a portrait that challenges the motivations of Pope Francis and clerics who desire to suppress the TLM.

 

In their yet-to-be-published book, sociologists Stephen Bullivant and Stephen Cranney used surveys, extended interviews, and ethnographic data to examine the question: Who are “Trads,” really?

 

In an interview with Jan C. Bentz published by The Catholic Herald, Bullivant first observed that “Traditional Latin Mass communities attract young Catholics and families” who show “high levels of religious commitment.”

 

“Ordinarily, these would seem precisely the characteristics the Church would wish to encourage. Yet that hasn’t always been the response,” noted Bullivant.

 

He shared his finding that many of those who attend TLMs also attend Novus Ordo Masses, defying the idea that “traditionalists constitute an entirely separate population from ordinary Catholics.” Just as many clergy offer both the Novus Ordo and Latin Mass, many of the laity attend both forms of the Mass, independent of restrictions that would force them to do so.

 

The researchers also found that while Latin Mass attendees are more likely to oppose the Second Vatican Council than those who only attend the Novus Ordo, about half of them support the council. They cited survey data indicating that 22 percent strongly agreed and 27 percent agreed that they accepted the teachings of Vatican II, according to OSV News. A reported 15 percent somewhat agreed, and 4 percent strongly disagreed that they accepted Vatican II’s teachings.

 

When asked whether Latin Mass-goers are attracted to the TLM because of their conservative politics, or they are drawn to conservatism because they attend the TLM, Bullivant made clear that while they do “heavily skew” conservative, their attraction to the Latin Mass cannot be reduced to politics.

 

He acknowledged that there is some correlation between “political, theological, and liturgical orientations,” and that Latin-Mass goers tend to subscribe to conservative views of family, sexuality, and dress.

 

“But when you ask people how they discovered the traditional Mass, the stories are remarkably varied,” he shared, noting that he and Cranney wrote a whole chapter on why people came to the TLM, and why they stayed.

 

Generally, said Bullivant, the reasons people attend the Latin Mass are not related to “some grand ideological project to restore Western civilisation,” but are rather “much more immediate and personal.”

 

The researcher also refuted the idea that Latin Mass-goers are defined by “opposition,” and are “contrarians.”

 

“My experience, both through the interviews and through years of irregularly attending traditional Latin Masses myself, is overwhelmingly of warm, welcoming communities,” said Bullivant. “What you encounter are people who love their faith and have a particular affection for a particular liturgy.”

 

If anything, Latin Mass attendees appeared to have a stronger devotion to their faith. Young families spoke to the researchers about their desire to find others “who took their faith seriously.”

 

“There was also genuine hurt about how traditionalists are portrayed, including by people in Rome. We repeatedly heard variations of the same sentiment: If only they actually knew us,” said Bullivant.

 

They stressed that certain abrasive “Trads” who have a loud presence online are not reflective of their church communities.

 

Bullivant suggested that bishops get to know the traditional communities in their dioceses, pointing out that for the “great majority” of them, “the traditional Latin Mass is hardly their most pressing concern.”

 

“Very few bishops are lying awake thinking, ‘We have too many young families and young adults who take their faith seriously. How can we get rid of some of them?’” 

https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/trads-book-exposes-lies-that-led-to-traditionis-custodes/

 

 

At Prevost's elbow, Dr Maria Alvarado, who says it's wrong to want Jews to become Catholic  

                                   


And the last word from Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano:


“The Catholic Church is under enemy occupation today. It still exists, even as a hierarchy, but it is under enemy occupation […].

 

In the face of this reality, it is clear that priests who wish to celebrate the ancient Roman Rite, as well as the faithful who wish to attend it, are not bound to obey any hierarchy that orders or plans illegitimate acts based on an abuse of power.

 

Any priest in the world can celebrate the ancient Roman Rite wherever he wants, whenever he wants, as provided for by the Church throughout the ages, by the Council of Trent and by Saint Pius V, and also, ultimately and paradoxically for modernists and conservatives, by Benedict XVI’s 2007 motu proprio “Summorum Pontificum.”

The dispensation is merely an illegitimate instrument of abuse of power.

Therefore, in the freedom of the children of God and of His one true Church, we don’t give a damn.

And where bishops close their doors and shut off our options, we will find private chapels, garages, apartments, hotel rooms, even the great outdoors, in which to celebrate and have celebrated the age-old Holy Mass in the ancient, apostolic Roman Rite. Because we are Catholics.https://x.com/CarloMVigano/status/2122766880326787482

 

 

Dedication of Basilicas of Ss Peter and Paul (Nov 18)

St Peter's Basilica

St Paul's Basilica


 "But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach a gospel other than the one we preached to you, let them be under God’s curse!" (St Paul, Galatians 1:8)